Maui wildfire death toll, already highest in modern U.S. history, could surge
NBCSep 01, 2023
The Facts
On Thursday, Maui County filed suit against Hawaiian Electric Company and its local subsidiaries for failing to shut down the county’s power despite extreme winds and dry conditions — connecting the company’s negligence to this month’s devastating wildfires.
The lawsuit claims Hawaiian Electric Company (known as "HECO") “inexcusably kept their power lines energized,” even though the National Weather Service disseminated a high wind watch and fire danger warning.
The Spin
Narrative A
Instead of acting to save lives, HECO sat by as its utility poles got knocked down and Lahaina burned. The lack of a formal shutoff program is an excuse that doesn’t withstand the evidence. HECO should be held accountable.
Narrative B
HECO used sound logic when it didn’t completely shut down Maui’s power. Hawaii needed electricity for firefighters and first responders to do their jobs. A power shutdown could have made the situation worse, and blaming one party for a complex problem does nothing to improve the situation. More context is needed here.
