Judge Dismisses Musk's Suit Against Nonprofit

story

Mar 26, 2024

Image copyright: Maja Hitij/Staff/Getty Images News via Getty Imagesstory last updated Mar 27

The Facts

Elon Musk-owned X's (formerly Twitter), lawsuit against the Center for Countering Digital Hate (CCDH), a nonprofit studying online hate speech, Monday was dismissed by a federal judge who ruled the suit was an attempt to silence a group that was speaking negatively about the platform.
X filed the suit in California in July 2023 after the CCDH published several articles claiming Musk's takeover of X was followed by an increase of hate speech on the platform.

The Spin

Narrative A

This suit and others like it are Musk's attempt to leverage his immense wealth to silence critics, despite his claims of being a free-speech absolutist. Throwing out this nuisance lawsuit was the best way for the courts to discourage Musk from continuing to pursue legal action to squelch free speech, and empower organizations like the CCDH to continue their work without fear of legal repercussions.

Guardian

Narrative B

Legal action is the only way for Musk to fight back against advocacy groups that disagree with the content on X. These groups attack the platform by telling advertisers lies about the content and then threaten those companies into pulling their money. Those groups are the true opponents of free speech and Musk has no choice but to sue them for putting the financial future of X in peril.