Trump Weighs DeSantis as Pentagon Pick Amid Hegseth Controversy

Above: Florida Gov Ron DeSantis speaks as he holds a copy of the amendment at his press conference about the marijuana constitution amendment on Monday, Nov. 4, 2024, at FIU Graham Center Ballroom in Miami, Fla. Image copyright: Carl Juste/Contributor/Miami Herald/Tribune News Service via Getty Images

The Facts

  • US Pres.-elect Donald Trump is reportedly considering Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis as a potential replacement for Pete Hegseth, his embattled defense secretary nominee, following mounting concerns about Hegseth's confirmation prospects.

  • Hegseth faces scrutiny over multiple allegations, including a 2017 sexual assault claim that resulted in a settlement agreement, and reports of misconduct during his leadership of veterans' organizations.


The Spin

Right Pro-Establishment Narrative

If Hegseth's controversies end up restricting him from Trump's cabinet, DeSantis would be an excellent replacement. With his unwavering ideological commitment, intellectual rigor, and proven success in managing government agencies, he embodies the qualities essential for meaningful reform and impactful leadership. If Trump truly wants to succeed in his second presidency, DeSantis' well-rounded experience will get him there.

Right Establishment-Critical Narrative

The media's baseless smearing of Pete Hegseth is a blatant attempt to derail Trump’s transition back to the White House, but the president must not let their defamation tactics win. These anonymous, unsubstantiated claims mirror the discredited attacks on Brett Kavanaugh. Hegseth’s colleagues continue to overwhelmingly defend his character, exposing these accusations as malicious fabrications unworthy of serious consideration.

Left narrative

DeSantis' consideration of this nomination reveals a deeper dependency on Trump than previously assumed. The governor's apparent fear of political irrelevance after his term ends is driving his interest in a role that has historically been a dead end for presidential aspirations. Should he accept, DeSantis risks cementing his legacy as a mere subordinate to Trump's authoritarian style of leadership.


Metaculus Prediction


Public figures in this story


Political split

LEFT

RIGHT

More neutral political stance articles