Referendum Could Give Australia's Indigenous Greater Say
TimeMAR 31 2023
The Spin
Left narrative
This referendum is perhaps the first serious chance Australia has to chart a new, equitable course for the country — one that includes the voices of the indigenous peoples of Australia. While not a perfect solution, the enshrinement of an indigenous advisory committee would help rectify Australia's shameful history of disenfranchisement and racism against the first peoples on the land. Australia should ignore the old guard and establish a new and fair relationship with indigenous Australians.
Right narrative
There is a myriad of reasons to oppose the voice referendum that have nothing to do with racism, despite claims from the left. The details of the powers and scope of the committee are currently unknown, with Labor effectively asking the public to vote blindly. The committee being permanently enshrined would also increase the risk of partisan capture or obstruction, which Australia cannot afford. Finally, to grant one group special status over any other is incompatible with the values of Australia and its multiracial society.