The Australian senator dividing the ruling Labor party over Palestinian statehood
GuardianJUN 2024
Australia: Labor's Pro-Palestine Senator Resigns
Image copyright: Matt Jelonek/Contributor/Getty Images News via Getty Images
The Spin
Narrative A
Payman's decision to cross the floor on the issue of Palestinian statehood, even at the risk of expulsion from her party, is a commendable act of integrity. Unlike others who may prioritize party solidarity, she followed her conscience, believing deeply in the need to recognize Palestinian statehood. This rare display of political courage and adherence to personal principles should be applauded.
Narrative B
Payman's stance is dangerous and needs to be condemned. She has undermined the Labor Party's longstanding commitment to a negotiated two-state solution. Besides jeopardizing party solidarity, she has ignored the complexities of Palestinian governance. In any case, Australian foreign policy isn't determined in the Senate. Payman's stance risks turning her into a martyr.