Australia Scrutinizes Israeli Soldiers' Visa Applications
The Facts
Two Israeli soldiers, Omer and Ella Berger, have been unable to enter Australia after being required to complete 13-pages of security declarations typically used for foreign fighters and government officials.
Omer, who's in the academic reserve program, and Ella, a member of the Intelligence Corps, were traveling with four relatives to celebrate their grandmother's 100th birthday. While their relatives received quick visa approvals, their applications faced additional scrutiny.
The Spin
Narrative A
This isn't an isolated incident and comes as no surprise given Australia's disturbing surge in anti-Semitism following Hamas' Oct. 7 attack. Reports of abuse, Nazi imagery, and attacks on Jewish institutions highlight the growing threat, while the government's inability to address this has left Jewish communities feeling unsafe.
Narrative B
This type of visa scrutiny isn't unique to just Israelis: it's a routine procedure for any military personnel involved in a war. Regardless, Australia remains committed to its fight against all forms of hate. From a counterterrorism task force to increased patrols and hate crime investigations, the government is actively combating anti-Semitism.
Cynical narrative
This is another example of Australia's increasingly questionable tactics that affect both sides of the issue. From banning Candace Owens for her alleged anti-Israel beliefs to banning former Israeli minister Ayelet Shaked for her pro-Israel beliefs, the government is stifling meaningful debate and exacerbating tensions.
