Six days of horror: America’s thirst for executions returns with a vengeance
GuardianOCT 2024
China Sentences Ex-Government Employee to Death for Alleged State Secrets Leak
Above: Tiananmen Gate featuring Mao Zedong's image is seen at night in Beijing on December 1, 2022. Image copyright: Jade Gao/Contributor/AFP via Getty Images
The Spin
Anti-China narrative
China's revised state secrets law and opaque death penalty practices are serious human rights concerns. By classifying execution data as state secrets, China obscures the true extent of its use of capital punishment — likely hiding thousands of executions. Recent legal changes grant authorities broad power to target foreign nationals and dissenters, expanding government control and stifling public discourse. These measures signal an alarming erosion of transparency, restricting accountability for potential human rights abuses in China.
Pro-China narrative
China's updated state secrets law is a necessary measure to protect national security while still fostering an open business environment. Despite criticism, these revisions aim to ensure technological and strategic interests are safeguarded without hindering legitimate foreign business operations. In parallel, China’s approach to capital punishment is balanced — applying strict, controlled use only for severe crimes, in line with China’s social context and judicial norms. This issue remains a sovereign matter.