France: Trial Begins in Beheading of Teacher Over Prophet Cartoons

France: Trial Begins in Beheading of Teacher Over Prophet Cartoons
Above: A person holds a placard with the portrait of Samuel Paty on Place de la Republique in Paris on Oct.18, 2020. Image copyright: BERTRAND GUAY/Contributor/AFP via Getty Images

The Spin

Narrative A

Samuel Paty's murder — which horrified France — was a direct attack on a democracy's fundamental values of freedom of expression and secularism in public life. The self-styled defenders of Islam must be held accountable for hating France's secular values, triggering an international hate campaign, and murdering a conscientious and much-liked history teacher.

Narrative B

This incident exemplifies how social media can amplify misunderstandings and transform personal grievances into dangerous hate campaigns, leading to tragic consequences. While this is a much-needed trial, prosecutors must maintain a careful balance between holding the offenders accountable without reviving the anti-Muslim rhetoric that was normalized following Paty's atrocious killing.

Metaculus Prediction


Articles on this story

Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters
Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters

Sign Up!
Sign Up Now!