‘We are with you’: Supporters applaud victim of mass rape in France
NBCSEP 2024
France Mass Rape Trial: Prosecutors Want 20-Year Sentence for Pelicot
Above: Gisele Pelicot leaves the courthouse after a hearing in the trial of her former partner Dominique Pelicot in Avignon, France on Nov. 19, 2024. Image copyright: CHRISTOPHE SIMON/Contributor/AFP via Getty Images
The Spin
Narrative A
France must reform its rape laws to prioritize consent and address systemic victim-blaming. The Dominique Pelicot case highlights these dangerous legal gaps, as current definitions of rape exclude consent violations. Societal and institutional changes — such as men calling out sexual misconduct when they see it — are also essential to end the normalization of gender-based violence.
Narrative B
While France should certainly work to enhance protections for victims, it's important to also maintain legal protections for the accused. Regarding the public nature of this trial, some senior lawyers have suggested that such information should only be scrutinized once individuals have been convicted to avoid stigma and judgment for those who are innocent. Anonymity is a key protection that should be afforded to all defendants.