At least 31 illegal miners killed in South Africa explosion only now coming to light
NBCJUL 2023
South Africa: Volunteers Enter Abandoned Mine Shaft to Help Illegal Miners
Above: Community members are searched by South African Police Service officers before entering the mine shaft to negotiate with artisanal miners underground to resurface in Stilfontein on Nov. 13, 2024. Image copyright: Emmanuel Croset/Contributor/AFP via Getty Images
The Spin
Narrative A
These illegal miners, who voluntarily went into the mine to conduct illicit business, must come back up on their own. If volunteers wish to go down themselves to deliver food, that's fine, but police officers shouldn't risk their lives to help criminals. They will come out eventually and face the prosecution they deserve.
Narrative B
This strategy is inhumane. While the government's frustration with illegal mining is reasonable, it shouldn't prevent them from saving human lives. After police rescue these individuals from starving to death, they can arrest and prosecute them — but until then, they should follow the principle of ubuntu and show compassion.