More than 2,000 Afghans still "arbitrarily detained" in UAE camp "exactly like a prison," rights group says
CBSDec 23, 2022
UAE: Over 40 Activists Receive Life Sentences for 'Terror' Offenses
Image copyright: Rustam Azmi/Contributor/Getty Images News via Getty Images
The Facts
On Wednesday, the United Arab Emirates (UAE) state news agency WAM reported that the Abu Dhabi Federal Court of Appeal sentenced 43 human rights advocates to life in prison for terror offenses and allegedly "creating a terrorist organization."
The court reportedly put 84 defendants on trial, the majority of whom had served more than 10 years in jail following similar convictions in 2013. Ten others received sentences ranging from 10 to 15 years in prison, according to news reports, while one was acquitted and 24 cases were deemed inadmissible.
The Spin
Pro-establishment narrative
This verdict was expected. It was clear from the beginning that the UAE court would impose excessive sentences in a trial that was shamelessly unjust and characterized by many violations of due process and torture allegations. The court violated basic legal principles, including double jeopardy and retroactive punishment, for actions that were not illegal at the time they were allegedly committed. This unlawful ruling must be overturned, and the prisoners should be set free.
Establishment-critical narrative
The Abu Dhabi Federal Court of Appeal handed down the sentences after finding that the convicted individuals had collaborated with a banned terrorist organization to instigate violent unrest in the country. This included protests and clashes between security forces and protesting crowds, which could have resulted in deaths, injuries, and property destruction. All convicted criminals have the right to appeal their verdicts to a higher court.