Mauritius holds out on Chagos Islands deal over Diego Garcia lease
GuardianDEC 14 2024
UK: Report Claims Mauritius Sought £800M/Year in Chagos Islands Deal
Above: The British Indian Ocean Territory (BIOT) or Chagos Islands (formerly the Oil Islands) — an overseas territory of the United Kingdom situated in the Indian Ocean. Image copyright: History/Contributor/Universal Images Group via Getty Images
The Spin
Left narrative
The UK owes Mauritius significant reparations for historical injustices, including the forced displacement of the Chagossians. The previous agreement, which accepted a low sum, failed to recognize the true value of Mauritius' maritime resources and agricultural potential. The blue economy, along with sustainable agriculture, offers immense economic opportunities that were overlooked. The UK must provide a fairer settlement, reflecting the full scope of these resources and the harm caused by its colonial actions.
Right narrative
Any Chagos Islands deal risks taxpayers' money and national security. The UK's sovereignty, particularly over Diego Garcia, is crucial for NATO and US defense. Mauritius' claim lacks legal basis, and ceding control could empower adversaries like China. The financial cost, potentially billions, is excessive — driven more by political motives than national interest. Rushing to finalize this deal jeopardizes both the UK's security and taxpayers' interests.