House votes to renew FISA spying tool after earlier Republican revolt
NBCAPR 2024
US House Clears 2-Year Reauthorization of Warrantless Surveillance
Image copyright: Samuel Corum/Getty Images News via Getty Images
The Spin
Narrative A
Section 702 permits the inadvertent capturing of Americans' data in "backdoor" searches that clearly violate privacy rights. Despite calls for reform and a push for a warrant requirement, the reauthorization lacks crucial safeguards. Past abuses necessitate oversight. A balance between national security and civil liberties is crucial.
Narrative B
Section 702 already balances civil liberties protection for Americans while targeting foreign threats as best as it can. It doesn't enable warrantless surveillance of Americans on US soil; court orders are only unnecessary for foreign targets located abroad. Requiring warrants for overseas intel gathering could hinder timely threat identification.