Vatican Museums faces unprecedented legal dispute over job conditions
GuardianMay 21
Vatican Museums Workers File Labor Complaint
Image copyright: Franco Origlia/Contributor/Getty Images News via Getty Images
The Facts
Employees at the Vatican Museums have launched a complaint over poor working conditions that could lead to legal action being taken against Pope Francis' governorate.
Forty-nine workers say that labor conditions at the Vatican Museums "violate their dignity and do not respect the basic rights of any worker," according to lawyer Laura Sgrò. The workers claim they work overtime hours at lower rates and endure subpar health and safety provisions.
The Spin
Narrative A
This mistreatment of employees has been going on for years and contradicts Catholic teaching about social justice and respect for the dignity of workers. The workers have no choice but to pursue legal action against Pope Francis' administration, and hopefully, the Holy See will begin honoring workers' rights to prevent this lawsuit from going further.
Narrative B
Pope Francis and his close allies have consistently advocated for social justice, fair labor practices, and an end to exploitative economic structures. The Holy See continues to fight for the dignity of all workers, and that includes the employees who work in Vatican City. It should be easy to resolve this legal matter if the workers' claims are legitimate.