Two Barnard College students expelled over hate-filled anti-Israel protest at Columbia University
New York PostFEB 28
Barnard College Expels Students Over Israel Class Disruption
Image copyright: Selcuk Acar/Contributor/Anadolu via Getty Images
The Spin
Narrative A
The classroom disruption represents a fundamental breach of academic principles and threatens the safety and integrity of the learning environment. The protesters targeted specific communities and courses with violent imagery and intimidating behavior, making decisive action necessary to maintain educational standards. The decision to expel these students was justified.
Narrative B
The protest was a legitimate form of student activism against what protesters viewed as problematic course content. The harsh punishment of expulsion represents a serious escalation in the crackdown on student activism and free speech regarding Palestinian rights.