Brazil: Bolsonaro Coup Trial Kicks Off

SEP 3·UPDATED SEP 9

story

+2

Above: The First Panel of the Brazilian Supreme Court starts Bolsonaro's coup trial on Sept. 2, 2025. Image copyright: Arthur Menescal/Bloomberg/Getty Images

The Spin

Left narrative

Brazil is setting a powerful example for the U.S. by holding former leaders accountable for attacking democratic institutions. No one, regardless of political position, stands above the law when they attempt to overthrow legitimate election results through violence and conspiracy. This historic trial shows how mature democracies should respond to authoritarian threats.

The Economist

Right narrative

Bolsonaro and his co-defendants will receive anything but a fair trial. It's impossible for the First Panel of the Brazilian Supreme Court to deliver an impartial judgment given that a majority of its justices are either close allies to Brazilian President Lula — Bolsonaro's rival — or longtime Bolsonaro nemesis Alexandre de Moraes. It's certain beforehand that Bolsonaro will be convicted.

X Twitter