The Biggest Challenges Pope Leo XIV Faces
TimeMAY 9
Leo XIV Conducts First Mass as Pope
Above: American Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost presides over his first Holy Mass as Pope Leo XIV with cardinals in the Sistine Chapel at the conclusion of the Conclave on May 9, 2025, in Vatican City, Vatican. Image copyright: Simone Risoluti/Vatican Media/Vatican Pool/Getty Images News via Getty Images
The Spin
Narrative A
Pope Leo XIV’s election is a hopeful moment for the global Church. With deep roots in Latin America and a life shaped by pastoral service and justice, he brings humility, wisdom, and a bridge-building spirit. His commitment to synodality and the poor echoes Pope Francis’ vision, offering steady leadership in a divided world. The Church is in capable, compassionate hands.
Narrative B
Pope Leo XIV begins his papacy facing deep challenges: restoring trust after abuse scandals, navigating division over LGBTQ+ inclusion, and defining the role of women in the Church. As the first American pope, he inherits a global Church in flux. Balancing reform with tradition, and unity with truth, will test his leadership like never before. All eyes are on him, and only time will tell.