Auction of ancient Indian gems ‘imbued with presence of Buddha’ condemned
Guardian7 days
India Halts Sotheby's Auction of Sacred Buddha Gems
Above: Gems with ties to early Buddhism exhibited at Sotheby's in Hong Kong on May 6, 2025. Image copyright: Tommy Wang/Contributor/AFP via Getty Images
The Spin
Narrative A
The Piprahwa gems, with ties to the Buddha's remains, are sacred to the Buddhist faith and integral to India's cultural heritage. Selling them to the highest bidder blatantly disregards their spiritual significance, violates Indian laws, and perpetuates colonial exploitation. These relics belong in Buddhist temples or museums, not auction houses, to honor their profound historical and religious value for global Buddhist communities.
Narrative B
The Piprahwa gems, inherited by the Peppé family for generations, have been responsibly shared through global museum exhibits and are not hoarded. Their auction ensures transparency, allowing a passionate buyer, potentially even a Buddhist, to continue their legacy. William Peppé donated most relics to India, the rest of which were legally retained. This sale respects their historical value, enables broader access, and honors the Buddha's universal teachings.