I’m changing my bill to ensure people have the right to a dignified death – here’s how
GuardianFEB 21
UK: Assisted Dying Bill Sponsor Proposes Swapping High Court Approval With Expert Panel
Above: Labour MP Kim Leadbeater joins terminally ill advocates, bereaved families, and campaigners for a photocall outside the House of Parliament on Oct. 9, 2024. Image copyright: Ben Whitley/PA Images via Getty Images
The Spin
Progressive narrative
Proposed changes to the assisted dying bill are a step forward in protecting the rights of terminally ill people while ensuring their safety. By introducing a Voluntary Assisted Dying Commission and expert panels, the bill addresses concerns about the unworkable demands on the High Court. These changes ensure robust safeguards without overburdening individuals during their final months.
Conservative narrative
Swapping High Court oversight with a so-called "expert panel" seriously risks weakening safeguards before this law has even passed. Removing judicial scrutiny could undermine protections for the vulnerable, handing significant power to unelected individuals operating without public accountability. This sets a dangerous precedent, and could be the start of a slippery slope in assisted dying legislation.