Afghanistan

Pakistan Strikes Kill 29 Militants in Afghanistan

Is this a necessary act of self-defense or a catastrophic blunder it cannot afford?

Published 1 day ago

Pakistan Strikes Kill 29 Militants in Afghanistan

Story

Above: A damaged rooftop after an attack by the Pakistani military in Asadabad, Kunar province on April 28. Image credit: Aimal Zahir/AFP/Getty Images

The Spin

Pro-Afghanistan narrative

Pakistan's assault on Afghanistan is morally indefensible and economically ruinous. With debt at 74.5% of GDP and interest payments devouring nearly 8% more, Islamabad is picking a fight that no one will win. This violence resolves nothing: both nations trade accusations over TTP and ISIS-K sanctuaries. What is needed now is serious diplomacy — a monitored, binding agreement of mutual non-interference. The time for negotiations is long overdue.

Eurasia Review

Zalmay Khalilzad on X

Pro-Pakistan narrative

Pakistan's military response to cross-border terrorism is a necessary act of self-defense against a Taliban regime that actively shelters TTP and IMP militants launching attacks on Pakistani civilians and security forces. The Afghan Taliban are fragmented, ideologically rigid and completely unwilling to honor U.N. resolutions demanding denial of sanctuary to terror networks. Kinetic pressure on the country — paired with diplomacy and regional coordination — is the only realistic path to dismantling these threats.

War Analyst on X Geo News