03 April 2024

Daily Newsletter

JK Rowling Won't Face Criminal Action Under Hate Crime Law

The Facts

  • Police Scotland has responded to Harry Potter author JK Rowling's criticism of Scotland's new Hate Crime law. It said that while they "have received complaints in relation to [her] social media post," they were "not assessed to be criminal."

  • The social media post in question, posted on X, formerly Twitter, began with Rowling listing several trans-identified biological men, including some convicted of child rape and possession of illicit images of children.


The Spin

Right narrative

This bill was obviously created to punish working-class people with less power than Rowling. So, while Rowling may be safe from veritable thought police, that doesn't mean regular people will be able to call a man a man and a woman a woman. This law protects the delusional at the expense of free thinking, and its vague nature seems to have been written so that, sooner or later, both women and men could face charges.

Left narrative

Nothing in this bill states that what Rowling said, or even misgendering more generally, would be a crime. Not only will the police face a high bar when it comes to who violates the law, but the law itself also protects free speech surrounding these exact topics. Just because hateful rhetoric is reported and investigated doesn't mean that the police will actually handcuff people for speaking their minds.

Nerd narrative

There's a 5.7% chance that Scotland will leave the United Kingdom before 2030, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Botswana Threatens to Ship 20K Elephants to Germany

The Facts

  • Botswana Pres. Mokgweetsi Masisi on Tuesday threatened to send 20K elephants to Germany amid a political row between the countries over restrictions on the importation of hunting trophies.

  • Masisi told German media that Germans should "live together with the animals, in the way you are trying to tell us to," adding that Botswana "would like to offer such a gift to Germany."


The Spin

Narrative A

This is an outlandish threat that shouldn't deter Germany from banning the import of hunting trophies. The unethical organizers of these hunting trips are the only ones who benefit from these activities, not the poor local residents or even the hunting authorities. Botswana shouldn't do anything to jeopardize its conservation achievements and should instead work with Germany on ways to protect its biodiversity.

Narrative B

His offer may sound bizarre, but it has a serious background, so Masisi's intentions are admirable. An ill-considered import ban would penalize countries like Botswana and undermine their immense wildlife conservation efforts. The so-called "developed" countries should first worry about their own fauna, abandon their neo-colonial attitude, and take local concerns seriously.

Nerd narrative

There's a 53% chance that space-based technologies will facilitate the creation of an effective global system for tracking and mitigating illegal wildlife trade before 2031, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Biden and Xi Hold First Conversation in Months

The Facts

  • US Pres. Joe Biden and his Chinese counterpart, Xi Jinping, held on Tuesday a nearly two-hour "candid and constructive" phone conversation in which contentious and cooperative issues were addressed.

  • This was the first time that the two leaders spoke with each other since they exchanged congratulations on the 45th anniversary of diplomatic ties between Beijing and Washington on Jan. 1.


The Spin

Democratic narrative

Pres. Biden made good use of his conversation with Xi as he raised several concerns over worrying international developments and defended the US. His administration is currently doing all it can to ensure peaceful and stable relations with Beijing — and even push for limited cooperation — as competition between the two powers increases.

Republican narrative

Another interaction with Xi, another show of weakness. Joe Biden has essentially done the same thing over and over again during his tenure, raising concerns to Beijing over a plethora of issues but not taking any step — either words or actions — to force China to halt its provocations.

Pro-China narrative

While this phone call is certainly a reassurance that tensions remain managed, the US continues to say one thing while doing another. There is handsome potential for both nations to thrive in the same global order but this will only occur if America focuses on actions rather than words, and respects its commitments to measures such as the One-China policy.

Nerd narrative

There's a 10% chance of a US-China war before 2035, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

At Least 9 Killed After Powerful Earthquake Shakes Taiwan

The Facts

  • A 7.4-magnitude earthquake struck the east coast of Taiwan on Wednesday, killing nine people and injuring more than 900. This is the strongest quake to hit the island in 25 years.

  • According to the United States Geological Survey, the quake struck southwest of Hualien City at 7:58 a.m. local time, with Taiwan recording at least 58 aftershocks.


The Spin

Narrative A

Since Taiwan lies on a tectonic boundary between the Eurasian Plate and the Philippine Sea Plate, the island is regularly jolted by earthquakes. However, the fact that Wednesday's powerful quake was felt in Shanghai, nearly 900 km (590 mi.) away, yet caused no significant damage or casualty shows that Taiwan's natural disaster response is world-class.

Narrative B

Taiwan may have a world-class seismological network, but its early warning system is still ancient, or Wednesday's massive earthquake wouldn't have taken aback the island. The quake will have a significant economic impact, particularly on Taiwan's semiconductor manufacturing sector, which provides nearly 90% of the world's most advanced microchips.

Nerd narrative

There's a 50% chance that at least 74.8K people will die as a result of the most deadly earthquake from 2020 to 2029, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Gaza: Biden 'Outraged' at Israeli Air Strike That Killed Aid Workers

The Facts

  • In the aftermath of Israeli airstrikes on a convoy of aid trucks that killed at least seven people in Gaza — including a US-Canada dual citizen and citizens of Australia, Poland, and the UK — US Pres. Joe Biden said Tuesday that he was "outraged and heartbroken" by the attack, before proceeding to issue some of his harshest warnings for Israel yet.

  • "This conflict has been one of the worst in recent memory in terms of how many aid workers have been killed," Biden said in a statement. He added, "Incidents like yesterday’s simply should not happen."


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

This was an appalling incident, and the strike on an aid convoy was only one in a string of incidents that has made this conflict the deadliest on record for aid workers. The US has consistently said that while it stands by Israel, it must do more to protect civilians from harm, and ensure the safe passage of humanitarian aid.

Establishment-critical narrative

This was another appalling Israeli attack on civilians and aid workers in what is an ongoing genocide. According to the World Central Kitchen, the aid convoy fully coordinated its movements with the IDF. This, combined with the fact that WCK is closely linked to British and US intelligence, raises more questions than it answers.

Pro-Israel narrative

Israeli is extremely sorry for this incident. It came at night, and in the fog of war, there was a case of misidentification that led to the airstrikes. Nonetheless, this shouldn't have happened. Israel is at war with Hamas, not the Palestinians in Gaza or the civilians distributing aid.

Nerd narrative

There's a 1% chance that the US will militarily intervene in the Israel-Gaza War before July 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Trump Countersues Truth Social Co-Founders

The Facts

  • Former Pres. Donald Trump is suing Andy Litinsky and Wes Moss, two co-founders of Trump Media & Technology Group — the publicly trading parent company of the social media platform Truth Social — over accusations the duo hindered the company's ability to go public sooner.

  • In a filing in a Florida court from March 24, Trump Media alleges Moss and Litinsky — who were once contestants on Trump's reality show "The Apprentice" — "failed spectacularly" while leading the company and caused "significant damage" to it by making poor decisions.


The Spin

Anti-Trump narrative

History shows that it's a reflex for the former president to sue anyone who works for or with him in any endeavor. So it's no surprise that even after taking Trump Media public and seeing a tremendous increase in his personal wealth, Trump has decided to sue two men who helped him get the company off the ground. This is quintessential Trump behavior.

Pro-Trump narrative

Trump had little choice but to sue Moss and Litinsky. They were granted a golden opportunity to amass great wealth alongside one of the most recognizable people in the world, and they fumbled it with terrible hirings and decisions that cost the company a great amount of its value. These two riders of Trump's coattails should be held accountable for their failures.

Nerd narrative

There's a 50% chance that Trump's net worth will be at least $2.54B on Dec. 31, 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Ukraine Lowers Conscription Age to 25

The Facts

  • In an effort to replace depleted troops, Pres. Volodymyr Zelenskyy on Tuesday signed a law to lower the military conscription age from 27 to 25. The law took effect Wednesday.

  • While all men aged 18-60 have been barred from leaving the country since the war began, only those 27 and older could be drafted by the government to fight.


The Spin

Pro-Ukraine narrative

Ukraine is facing several issues surrounding manpower, among which is certainly a need for new conscripts. The government could also work to rotate its frontline troops — most of whom have not had a break in two years — to the back and replace them with the hundreds of thousands of others who have yet to face the frontline.

Pro-Russia narrative

Zelenskyy is about to pull an even younger generation of Ukrainians onto the battlefield despite his past efforts failing to defeat Russian forces. As he lowers the conscription age, he's citing the lie that Russia intends to mobilize another 300K soldiers by June as a reason to rebuild his forces. Ukraine couldn't win with its original force and will continue to lose after this latest move.

Nerd narrative

There's a 50% chance that there will be a bilateral cease-fire or peace agreement in the Russo-Ukraine conflict by April 2026, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Tesla Production Decreased in Q1 2024

The Facts

  • Elon Musk-owned Tesla saw an 8% year-over-year decrease in electric vehicle (EV) production, with just 387K vehicles handed over in Q1 as the company dealt with a European plant fire and global shipping disruptions.

  • Analysts had expected around 455K vehicles for Q1, but those expectations were lowered in recent weeks. This was the first reported decline in deliveries since 2020 when the COVID pandemic disrupted operations.


The Spin

Narrative A

This news is nothing to panic about. Tesla has sold more vehicles in the first quarter than its biggest competitor — Chinese carmaker BYD — regaining its position as the world's leading seller of EVs. Musk has a strategy and is likely to continue to outperform all other EV manufacturers.

Narrative B

Tesla is facing multiple problems, including increased competition. The root cause of Tesla's problems could be Elon Musk, as many observers believe the company would be better off if he stepped down as chief executive officer and focused solely on innovation. Musk's controversial social media posts and his association with right-wing politics may be negatively affecting sales.

Nerd narrative

There's a 10% chance that Tesla will become the largest car company in the world (by sales) before Jan. 1, 2035, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Tenn. Passes Bill Banning Geoengineering

The Facts

  • Tennessee’s General Assembly on Monday passed bill SB2691, which "prohibit[s] the intentional injection, release, or dispersion" of chemicals or similar substances into the atmosphere "with the express purpose of affecting temperature, weather, or the intensity of the sunlight."

  • The bill was sponsored by state Rep. Monty Fritts and state Sen. Steve Southerland, both Republicans, who say there was "widespread documentation" of geoengineering, practices that use chemical compounds to manage climate change and "solar impact."


The Spin

Democratic narrative

Republicans have gone off the rails. This is a case of them spreading debunked conspiracy theories and passing a law to ban something that's non-existent. The conspiracy theories aside, this bill focuses on geoengineering, which is an undefined collection of hypothetical practices that have never been tested. This is a waste of time and resources.

Republican narrative

Democrats and their media allies want to smear Republicans over this bill, but there's no mention of "chemtrails" and it in fact deals with geoengineering — a practice the government released a report about last year. Some media pundits are changing their tune about geoengineering and Republicans will continue to fight the lies and protect their constituents.

Nerd narrative

There's a 3% chance that a geoengineering act of Congress will become US federal law by the end of 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Trump Docs Case: Special Counsel Criticizes Judge's Order

The Facts

  • In a filing Tuesday, special counsel Jack Smith's team criticized a request from the judge presiding over the case involving Pres. Donald Trump's alleged retention of classified documents after his presidency.

  • Smith's team wrote that US District Judge Aileen Cannon relied on a "fundamentally flawed legal premise" when she asked the prosecution and defense to propose jury instructions on the scenarios in which Trump could be protected under the Presidential Records Act (PRA).


The Spin

Anti-Trump narrative

With this filing, Smith dismantled any notion Trump could be protected by the PRA, and he's schooling Cannon on how to apply the law in this case. The PRA doesn’t apply to a president who was out of office for more than a year, and Smith knows this is just Trump's way of stalling. If Cannon doesn’t adhere to established legal principles, Smith will have no choice but to appeal.

Pro-Trump narrative

Smith is obviously growing frustrated because his case is falling apart, so he's taking out his anger on Cannon. In his haste to prosecute Trump, Smith can't handle the fact that the judge wants to make sure the jury is provided everything it needs to reach a proper decision. Smith may want to get this case to trial before the November election, but Cannon knows there are steps that need to be taken to ensure proper justice.

Nerd narrative

There's a 50% chance that Trump’s classified documents trial will begin by June 2025, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Sign up to our daily newsletter