17 April 2024

Daily Newsletter

Chinese President Meets with German Chancellor

The Facts

  • German Chancellor Olaf Scholz met with Chinese Pres. Xi Jinping and Premier Li Qiang in Beijing on Tuesday as part of a four-day visit to China.

  • According to China's Foreign Ministry, Xi and Scholz engaged in talks at the Diaoyutai State Guesthouse where the two discussed trade restrictions, climate change, EU-China relations, Russia-Ukraine, and Israel-Palestine.


The Spin

Pro-China narrative

Tuesday's meeting between Pres. Xi and Chancellor Scholz is a testament to the ever-growing relationship between China and Germany. With both economies now deeply intertwined, the highly successfully working relationship between the two countries highlights what can be achieved when East and West choose to cooperate. Together, China and Germany will only prosper as they continue communicating from positions of respect and strength.

Anti-China narrative

By speaking of open and fair cooperation with Beijing, Scholz's Germany has shown itself to be nothing but naïve in believing that its ultra-dependent relationship with China will benefit anything but Pres. Xi's long-term political goals. Scholz's inability to adequately stand up to Xi is further proof that Europe must not become fragmented in its battle against China. Germany already made the calamitous mistake in recent history of believing Russia could be rationally trusted — this cannot happen again with Beijing.

Nerd narrative

There is a 50% chance that the next "Great Power" war will take place by 2038, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Russia Claims Ukraine Would Use 'Olympic Truce' to Regroup

The Facts

  • Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov has responded skeptically to French Pres. Emmanuel Macron's call for a break in global conflicts during this year's summer Olympics, which is being hosted by Paris.

  • Macron on Tuesday said France would do everything possible to observe a cease-fire in Ukraine, Gaza, and Sudan between Jul. 26 and Aug. 11, including engaging the Chinese Pres. Xi Jinping in the effort.


The Spin

Anti-Russia narrative

Holding a cease-fire during the Olympic Games is a tradition dating back to the ancient Greeks and should be honored around the world. Macron isn't just calling for Russia and Ukraine to lay down their weapons for two weeks, but for all warring factions to take a peaceful break from the cycle of violence.

Pro-Russia narrative

Ukraine has typically used cease-fire suggestions to rearm itself, so Russia must exercise caution and consider its own national security interests. Moscow has also been the one calling for actual peace agreements to end the war, but it refuses to take a temporary pause just because Kyiv is running out of bullets.

Nerd narrative

There's a 4% chance that there will be a bilateral cease-fire or peace agreement in the Russo-Ukraine conflict in 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Heavy Rains, Rare Flash Floods Batter Dubai

Photo: Unsplash

The Facts

  • Severe storms lashed the United Arab Emirates on Tuesday, unleashing nearly two years' worth of rain on the desert city of Dubai in just 24 hours.

  • According to the UAE National Center of Meteorology, nearly 6.26 inches (159 mm) of rain fell over the emirate, which receives 3.14 inches (80 mm) of rain on average per year.


The Spin

Narrative A

Extreme weather events in Dubai — known for its dry conditions and arid climate — raise concerns about the increasingly evident impact of climate change in a region unaccustomed to heavy rain and flash flooding. Before exceptional weather becomes a regularity in the future as the planet warms, the UAE — one of the world's biggest oil producers — must curb carbon emissions to mitigate the potentially dangerous impacts of climate change.

Narrative B

The rains that swamped Dubai resulted from a larger storm system traversing the Arabian Peninsula and moving across the Gulf of Oman, bringing unusually wet weather. It's far too early to indicate that climate change played a role in the massive storms. Moreover, the city experienced rare flooding because its infrastructure wasn't designed to handle such unexpected rare weather events — given the lack of regular rainfall.

Nerd narrative

There's a 95% chance that there will be at least 2˚C of global warming by 2100, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

UK: Muslim Student Loses Prayer Ban Case

The Facts

  • An unnamed student has lost a UK High Court challenge against a prayer ban imposed by her secondary school in northwest London.

  • The unnamed student sued Brent's Michaela Community School, claiming the ban unfairly targeted her faith and that the school's stance alienated religious minorities.


The Spin

Narrative A

Schools should not be places of worship. Instead, they must strive to be academic powerhouses that emphasize discipline, inclusivity, and a focus on education above all else. This entails embracing a diverse student body while prioritizing unity and academic excellence. Effective leadership in education must transcend all cultural and religious boundaries.

Narrative B

Michaela Community School's strict secularism clashes with its diverse student body, raising questions about true cultural inclusivity. While promoting British values and religious development is crucial, this doesn't have to be at the expense of private spiritual worship. The High Court's acknowledgment of indirect discrimination against Muslims while doing nothing to remedy the issue is further proof that Islamophobia continues to be normalized within British society.

See sources

US, China Defense Chiefs Hold First Talks in 18 Months

The Facts

  • US Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin held a video call with China's National Defense Minister Dong Jun on Tuesday, marking the first direct conversation between both countries' defense chiefs in almost 18 months.

  • The two discussed bilateral defense ties and regional and global security issues, with Austin stressing the importance of expanding "military-to-military communication," according to the Pentagon.


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

The talks between the defense chiefs underline the US desire to put bilateral military ties back on a solid footing. This is especially necessary as the risk of unintended escalation increased due to Beijing's hostile intercepts of US aircraft and threats to Taiwan and other regional US allies. The US will continue to operate safely and responsibly where international law permits, and as mutual trust improves further, Beijing will realize that competition must not end in conflict.

Establishment-critical narrative

China welcomes the Austin-Dong talks, as building trust and defense ties is crucial for developing stable relations and preventing major crises. However, to avoid jeopardizing the encouraging progress, the US should refrain from playing a double game and take practical steps to maintain regional peace and stability. Beijing rejects any zero-sum logic, and peaceful coexistence is possible as long as China's territorial sovereignty and maritime rights are respected.

Nerd narrative

There is a 32% chance that China will launch a full-scale invasion of Taiwan by 2035, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Trump Manhattan Trial: First Jurors Selected

The Facts

  • The first seven out of 12 jurors have been selected in former US Pres. Donald Trump's hush-money trial in Manhattan. Another five jurors are now needed as well as six alternates.

  • More than half of the jury pool was excused at once, leaving the jury with three women and four men from Manhattan. They include a charter school teacher, a software engineer, a salesman, a corporate lawyer, and an oncology nurse.


The Spin

Anti-Trump narrative

While Trump complains that he can't possibly get a fair trial in a city that voted overwhelmingly against him, the history of well-instructed jurors proves otherwise. Every juror chosen will have undergone a lengthy selection process full of questionnaires and one-on-one consultations with the judge and lawyers. The only unexpected trouble Trump could face is anything he brings upon himself by impulsively speaking in violation of court rules.

Pro-Trump narrative

Not only has District Attorney Alvin Bragg turned a normal campaign finance violation into a bogus felony charge, but the judge, in this case, has allowed clearly compromised people onto the jury. For instance, one woman Judge Merchan allowed on the jury allegedly attended an anti-Trump event in 2020. Revealing the occupations of these jurors was also a bad decision by the court — if their identities are uncovered it could compromise their decisions in this blue city trial.

Nerd narrative

There's a 75% chance that Donald Trump will be found guilty of any crime in the Manhattan case before Election Day 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

NPR Editor Resigns After Publishing Essay Alleging Left-Leaning Bias

Photo: Verity

The Facts

  • Uri Berliner, an employee of National Public Radio (NPR) for 25 years who had been suspended after publishing an essay accusing the network of liberal bias, resigned from the media outlet on Wednesday.

  • In a statement on X, Berliner said he had quit after being "disparaged" by NPR's Chief Executive Officer — claiming their "divisive views" confirmed the "very problems at NPR I cited in my Free Press essay."


The Spin

Left narrative

Berliner deserved disciplinary action for not reaching out to NPR before publishing his op-ed. While he was entitled to free speech as a private citizen, Berliner had no right to violate NPR's internal policy as a journalist on its payroll. By going to another news outlet with his network's scathing criticism, the veteran editor violated trust and reached the point of no return.

Right narrative

Berliner has paid the price for exposing NPR's far-left-leaning bias. No longer focused on truth, the organization has moved from objective reporting to partisan favoritism. As political polarization continues to grow, Berliner's resignation should stir up a fresh debate around taxpayer-funded public media's sizeable shift to appease the far left.

Nerd narrative

There's a 75% chance that the US will continuously be a liberal democracy until 2040, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Biden: US Support for Israel Will Prevent Iranian Escalation

The Facts

  • In an op-ed published Wednesday, US Pres. Joe Biden called on Congress to pass legislation providing military aid to Israel and Ukraine, adding that his admin. will not write "blank checks." Biden argued that by readily supporting Israel, the US could prevent Iran from escalating the conflict.

  • Qatari Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani said on Wednesday that negotiations regarding the release of Israeli hostages and a cease-fire in Gaza have reached a "delicate phase," referring to an unspecified "stumbling block."


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

The US is doing everything it can to ensure that Israel deter military threats while also preventing regional escalation. Israel must be able to defend itself from terrorist attacks, whether from Gaza or elsewhere, and the US will always defend Israel's right to security. Nonetheless, it's not in the US or Israel's best interest to see the conflict escalate. Thankfully, Israel, with the assistance of the US and its regional allies, managed to effectively counter Iran's attack, and any further military actions are completely unnecessary.

Pro-Israel narrative

The US-Israeli relationship is one of the best strategic investments the US has made in the last 50 years. Besides the fact that arms sales to Israel directly support American industry, Israel's security is the US' security, as both countries are fighting the same enemies. Of course, the US and Israel do not agree on everything, having their ups and downs, but, nonetheless, US support for Israel effectively guarantees the US a strong position in the Middle East.

Pro-Palestine narrative

Reflexive US support for Israel over the decades has finally culminated in a horrifying display of human brutality — mass famine against the Palestinian people. Besides moral consideration around supporting Israel's slaughter in Gaza, Israel has consistently proven time and time again that it is a bad ally that is highly unreliable. While American and Israeli interests continue to diverge, successive American leaders have failed to recalibrate. Now, the US is risking a regional war by supporting a rogue Israeli state.

Pro-Iran narrative

Iran continues to demonstrate its capabilities and restraint, as the attack over the weekend will hopefully serve as a wake-up call to Israel to end this series of escalations. Iran and its allies have been clear from day one that they do not want to see this war spiral into a regional conflict. Rather, Iran only seeks to end Israel's crimes in Gaza, to which it has been forced to respond. Israel made a mistake in believing that Iran would not respond to its provocations, and Iran's leadership will continue to calculate its moves appropriately.

Nerd narrative

There's a 1% chance that Hamas will have de facto power in the Gaza Strip on Jan. 1, 2025, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Boeing Whistleblower Testifies Before US Senate

The Facts

  • Boeing whistleblower Sam Salehpour told the Senate Homeland Security and Government Affairs Subcommittee on Investigations on Wednesday that the company has produced defective airplanes, with gaps much wider than what its own standards allow.

  • According to the quality engineer at Boeing, the planemaker has sped up the production of its 787 and 777 aircraft and ignored safety standards. On Monday, Boeing challenged these allegations.


The Spin

Narrative A

For years, there have been whistleblower leaks and government warnings about the safety of Boeing's planes — those concerns came to a head after a door plug blew out on an Alaska Airlines flight in January. Boeing's greed and fixation on profits led the company to cut corners on quality control and created a culture of intimidation. Numerous whistleblowers have spoken out against Boeing's reaction to safety hazard reports, but the company is clearly more concerned with a culture of silence than it is with safety.

Narrative B

While the "profits-over-people claims" that media in the US has pushed to explain Boeing's safety problems may be appealing, the very idea that safety and shareholder returns are inversely related is entirely wrong — in fact, safety has enormously increased since the aviation industry was reorganized on competitive profit-and-loss lines in the 1970s. Boeing indeed has at least partial responsibility in recent incidents, these problems will be eventually sorted out with training, repetition, standardization, and documentation.

Nerd narrative

There's a 3% chance that commercial passengers will routinely fly in pilotless planes by 2030, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Sign up to our daily newsletter