Clinton Suggests Charging Americans for Spreading Russian Propaganda

Above: Former US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton during day one of the Democratic National Convention at the United Center in Chicago, Illinois on Aug.19, 2024. Image copyright: Demetrius Freeman/Contributor/The Washington Post via Getty Images

The Facts

  • Former US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton on Monday suggested "civilly or even in some cases criminally" charging Americans found engaging in Russian propaganda.

  • Clinton told MSNBC that both Russians and alleged US-based accomplices should be held accountable, and claimed that influence operations have become more "sophisticated" since 2016.


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

Hillary Clinton's stance underscores the need for global media and social media security. Russian propaganda's impact on public discourse is a "weapon of mass distraction." Artificial intelligence may be a potential tool to counter fake news, but trusted media platforms must also educate citizens. The importance of protecting democratic societies from disinformation aligns with broader concerns about safeguarding truth.

Establishment-critical narrative

Hillary Clinton's outrageously hypocritical call for criminal charges against Americans engaging in misinformation only heightens concerns about attempts by government-industrial complexes to dictate the parameters of "truth." Legal efforts to control speech undermine a free media ecosystem. Clinton herself has a checkered history with "misinformation" and her recent calls endanger civil liberties and encourage a surveillance state.


Metaculus Prediction


Public figures in this story


Establishment split

CRITICAL

PRO