Asteroid Chunk Collected by NASA After Desert Landing

Image copyright: Wikimedia Commons

The Spin

Narrative A

While some will argue studying a bunch of space rocks is a waste of time and money, celestial missions like the OSIRIS-REx are necessary for understanding how the Earth formed and the potential risks of asteroids and meteorites colliding with Earth. Furthermore, the existence, or at least potential existence, of water has been found on space rocks like Bennu, which provides scientists with a puzzle piece in the quest to find extraterrestrial life. If we wish to understand our solar system and protect Earth from enormous flying rocks, we best not defund the only agency in search of such answers.

Narrative B

The fact isn't that NASA programs are useless, but when Congress first funded the planetary defense program almost 20 years ago, it didn't expect a 4,000% budget increase while allocating less than 1% of it to actually defending the Earth from incoming asteroids. NASA, along with the congressmen who see over the agency, must revert to its original promise to study planetary defense of interplanetary objects — otherwise, space exploration is simply a bottomless pit with no fiscal responsibility that the American people can't afford right now.

Metaculus Prediction


Articles on this story

Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters
Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters

Sign Up!
Sign Up Now!