Biden calls U.S. ally Japan ‘xenophobic,’ along with China and Russia
NBCAPR 2024
Biden Calls Allies India, Japan 'Xenophobic'
Image copyright: Zhang Xiaoyo/Pool/Getty Images News via Getty Images
The Spin
Narrative A
Washington's relationship with its Asian allies is both important and enduring. The US president was simply making a broader point about the country's immigration policy. He meant no offense to India or Japan, as they share the same commitment to democracy, freedom, and dignity as America.
Narrative B
Grouping key allies, particularly when it comes to combating China, with longtime adversaries is irrational, especially when the US has its own problems with xenophobia. It's patronizing to disrespect India — the fastest-growing major economy in the world — and Japan — the first Asian country to achieve the developed economy label.