Supreme Court to hear dispute over Starbucks firing pro-union workers
NBCDec 31, 2023
SCOTUS to Hear Starbucks-Labor Union Dispute
Image copyright: Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images News via Getty Images
The Facts
The US Supreme Court (SCOTUS) on Friday said it will hear Starbucks' appeal against an order of the US Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit to re-hire seven baristas fired in 2022, allegedly for attempting to unionize.
Memphis-based US District Judge Sheryl Lipman initially granted an injunction to the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) to press Starbucks to re-employ its workers at a store in Memphis, who it claimed had been ousted in retaliation for their union activity.
The Spin
Pro-establishment narrative
Starbucks is merely applying the law of the land, yet is being punished with litigation. Why should the company's safety reputation be staked on the whims of a few employees? The workers who were fired, along with the bodies representing them, have been graceless in rebuffing the cafe chain's many conciliatory overtures made in good faith. The labor union is looking for blood.
Establishment-critical narrative
Starbucks is in a war of attrition against its rapidly unionizing workforce. The company is nipping away at the workers' morale and spirit in plain sight, playing underhand tricks against legitimate attempts at collectivization. Starbucks must be held accountable for resorting to threats, spying, harassment, and firing to browbeat its employees away from any thought of organizing.