No Squid Game? Or Patrick Schwarzenegger? This year’s biggest Emmy surprises
Guardian3 days
2025 Emmy Nominations Snubs and Surprises
Above: Apple TV+ Severance advertisement. Image copyright: Eakin Howard/Getty Images
The Spin
Narrative A
The Emmy nominations reflect a clear preference for fresh content over established favorites. Shows like "The Studio" and "Severance" rightfully dominated because they represent innovative storytelling that pushes television forward. The snubbing of repetitive series, such as the second season of "Squid Game," shows that voters recognize when shows lose their creative spark.
Narrative B
These nominations reveal a troubling bias against proven quality programming. Beloved series like "The Handmaid's Tale" and established stars like Elisabeth Moss deserved recognition for their final season work. The Academy's obsession with trendy new shows over consistent excellence undermines the credibility of the awards.