Canadian intelligence accuses India over Sikh’s killing as Carney meets Modi
Guardian2 days
Canadian Intelligence Accuses India of Foreign Interference
Above: Pro-Khalistan supporters in front of the Consulate General of India in Toronto, Ontario, on Oct. 18, 2024. Image copyright: Mert Alper Dervis/Anadolu via Getty Images
The Spin
Narrative A
Carney's invitation to Modi and the rushed restoration of diplomatic relations undermine justice for Nijjar's murder. Despite recent diplomatic efforts to mend ties, India continues to pose a threat of foreign interference to Canada. Covert influence operations and the targeting of diaspora communities persist, raising concerns about the sincerity of renewed engagement. Diplomatic overtures should not come at the expense of transparency and justice and must be matched by transparent actions to ensure respect for Canada's sovereignty and democratic institutions.
Narrative B
India has consistently voiced legitimate concerns about Khalistani extremists operating from Canadian soil, concerns that Canada has long failed to adequately address. The report underscores the presence of such elements in Canada, effectively validating India's longstanding warnings. Rather than acknowledging these threats, Canada's intelligence services acted prematurely and irresponsibly by labeling India as a perpetrator of foreign interference. Canada's stance appears reckless, reactive, and politically motivated, ignoring the deeper security risks posed to both nations.