‘Who is going to face Mr Trump’: Canada leaders’ debate dominated by US crisis
GuardianAPR 11
Canadian Election: Party Leaders Face Off in English Debate
Above: Party leaders participate in the English-language federal leaders' debate in Montreal on April 17, 2025. Image copyright: Christopher Katsarov/Contributor/Pool/Anadolu via Getty Images
The Spin
Liberal Party narrative
The English debate reinforced Carney's image as a serious, steady leader and a credible crisis manager. Under sustained attacks from all sides, he held firm and made clear he is not Trudeau, offering a fresh start for the Liberals. Carney emphasized the need for strong, strategic partnerships and level-headed leadership to navigate Trump-era trade threats and build a more resilient, forward-looking Canada.
Conservative Party narrative
After a decade of Liberal failure, Poilievre offered Canadians a hopeful path forward, grounded in common sense and real change. While Carney focused on fear and U.S. President Donald Trump, Poilievre laid out a plan to restore the Canadian promise: tackle the cost of living, build affordable homes, and make communities safer. The debate made clear this election is a choice between fear of the future—or hope for a better one.
New Democratic Party narrative
In the English-language debate, Singh showcased his fighting spirit, challenging leaders on key issues and standing up for Canadians. His interruptions reflected his determination to call out policies that benefit the rich and neglect the working class. Singh also raised critical questions about Carney's past and budget plan, highlighting the risks of cuts to essential services like healthcare. Singh is the only leader truly ready to fight for a better future.
Bloc Québécois Party narrative
Blanchet stood out as a strong, pragmatic advocate for Quebec in the debate. He fiercely defended provincial interests, ensuring Quebec's needs were front and center, challenged Carney on key issues with sharp wit and quick remarks, and reminded the NDP of their past oil subsidy votes. Blanchet's focus on Quebec's future proved he's the leader the province can rely on to safeguard its priorities.