David Souter, Supreme Court Justice and a Bush nominee who veered to the left, dies at 85
CNNMAY 7
Former Supreme Court Justice Souter Dies
Above: Retired U.S. Supreme Court Justice David Souter speaks ,at the New York State Museum on Sept. 12, 2013. Image copyright: Michael P. Farrell/Contributor/Albany Times Union via Getty Images
The Spin
Left narrative
Souter represented the ideal of a truly independent judiciary, approaching each case with careful consideration rather than ideological preconceptions. His evolution demonstrated intellectual honesty and commitment to justice over partisan loyalty, proving that judges can grow and adapt their understanding as society changes.
Right narrative
Souter's betrayal of conservative principles was inexcusable. He fundamentally changed the judicial nomination process, leading to the rise of the Federalist Society and the need for intense ideological screening of nominees. His leftward shift guaranteed future Republican administrations would work hard to avoid a repeat of his evolution.