French Ex-Surgeon Admits Guilt for All Criminal Charges in Child Abuse Trial

story

MAR 21

Above: a court sketch created on March 6, 2025, showing retired French surgeon Joel Le Scouarnec (R) answering a question during his trial on charges of assaulting or raping 299 patients, at the Criminal Court in Vannes Image copyright: Benoit PEYRUCQ/AFP/Contributor via Getty Images

story last updated MAR 21

The Spin

Narrative A

The medical establishment failed to protect patients by allowing Le Scouarnec to continue practicing after his 2005 conviction, demonstrating a systemic failure in France's healthcare oversight and a culture of silence that enabled decades of abuse. This should have never happened.

New York Post CNN

Narrative B

Le Scouarnec's admission of guilt for all the charges represents a pivotal moment in the pursuit of justice and healing for the victims, marking a turning point in France's largest child abuse case. While no measure of accountability can undo the profound harm he caused, hopefully, this is a step toward a sense of closure for the victims of his heinous crimes.

WION Guardian