Harvard Chooses Defiance
Atlantic3 days
Harvard Rejects Trump's Demands, Loses $2.2B in Funding
Above: A pedestrian passes Harvard Yard. Image copyright: Craig F. Walker/Contributor/The Boston Globe via Getty Images
The Spin
Republican narrative
Universities like Harvard, which accept billions in taxpayer funding, have a legal and moral duty to uphold civil rights laws—not defy them. The Trump administration's reforms aren't about censorship or "control"—they're about restoring accountability, merit, and safety for Jewish students amid rising antisemitism. If Harvard wants full independence, it can refuse federal funds, but it can't take taxpayer money while disregarding civil rights and enabling discrimination.
Democratic narrative
The Trump administration's demands go far beyond addressing antisemitism—they aim to reshape higher education through political pressure. Harvard's refusal to comply isn't just about one school—it's a stand for academic freedom and against government overreach. At this moment, Harvard must lead by example and defend its core values against coercion. Now more than ever, institutions must stand firm in their principles.