Last living grandson of 10th U.S. President John Tyler, a link to a bygone era, dies at 96
CBS2 days
Last Grandson of 10th US President Dies, Ending Unique Historic Link
Above: A statue of President John Tyler is seen as people take part in a tour to visit busts of United States Presidents on Saturday, May 28, 2022, outside of Williamsburg, Virginia Image copyright: Matt McClain/Contributor/The Washington Post via Getty Images
The Spin
Narrative A
John Tyler’s immediate lineage, with a grandson living until recently, is chronologically fascinating, but his legacy is marred by political failures and racism. His stubbornness, while setting a precedent for a fully empowered vice-presidential succession, led to ineffective governance, alienating his own party. A slave-owning states' rights advocate, Tyler was also out of touch with a changing America and later supported the Confederacy, betraying his nation.
Narrative B
While modern perspectives condemn John Tyler for his racism and Confederate ties, such disdain oversimplifies a complex historical figure. His commitment to states' rights and constitutional principles, rooted in his era's context, deserves nuanced respect. Like many in civil wars — English, American Revolution, or Civil War — Tyler's choices reflected his cultural and political reality, not just a moral failing. Judging him solely through today's lens distorts history.