Milwaukee Judge Convicted of Obstructing Federal Agents

Is Judge Dugan's conviction justice for obstructing ICE, or dangerous federal overreach that threatens judicial independence?

Published DEC 19 2025

Milwaukee Judge Convicted of Obstructing Federal Agents

story

Above: Judge Hannah Dugan leaves the Milwaukee Federal Courthouse on May 15, 2025. Image credit: Scott Olson/Getty Images

The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

Dugan betrayed her oath by obstructing federal immigration enforcement and helping an illegal alien escape from ICE agents. Fellow judges testified she admitted using judicial authority to block federal officers in a public hallway, proving institutional sabotage against law enforcement. This conviction sends a clear message that nobody is above the law.

Amuse on X

Scott Walker on X

Todd Blanche on X

Establishment-critical narrative

This is dangerous federal overreach. Federal agents intimidating court users and pressuring judges undermines the integrity of the justice system and due process protections. This prosecution raises serious constitutional questions about whether the executive branch crossed lines meant to protect the judiciary from political interference.

Democracy Defenders Fund Wisconsin Democracy Campaign