Lawmakers outraged over Padilla's forcible removal from Noem press conference
CBS1 day
Senator Padilla Forcibly Removed from DHS LA Press Conference
Above: Sen. Alex Padilla is removed from a DHS press conference in Los Angeles on June 12, 2025. Image copyright: Luke Johnson/Los Angeles Times/Getty Images
The Spin
Republican narrative
Padilla created a dangerous security situation by storming into a press conference without proper identification, lunging toward the Secretary, and refusing to comply with repeated commands to back away. Law enforcement acted appropriately to protect Secretary Noem from what appeared to be an aggressive threat. This wasn't an oversight — it was staged political theater designed to create a spectacle.
Democratic narrative
Padilla was exercising legitimate congressional oversight when he was violently dragged out for simply trying to question immigration policies affecting his constituents. If this is how the Trump administration treats a senator, imagine how it treats immigrant families. We must defend the First Amendment, protect the right to peaceful dissent, and expose this administration's cruel anti-immigrant agenda.
Left narrative
Padilla's violent removal isn't an isolated case — it's the latest sign of an administration sliding toward authoritarianism. From arresting peaceful lawmakers to deploying troops against civilians, Trump's team is dismantling democratic safeguards. When even the Defense Secretary won't commit to following court rulings, it's not law and order — it's raw power. This must be stopped.
Right narrative
Democrats like Schumer and Newsom are outraged over law enforcement doing their job, but silent on the violent riots targeting ICE agents across Los Angeles. Padilla stormed a secure briefing and ignored repeated commands — yet they blame the officers, not the chaos he helped fuel. Their priorities are upside down. Defending law and order shouldn't be controversial — it should be common sense.