Trevor Bauer Wins $309,000 Judgment Against Sexual Assault Accuser

Trevor Bauer Wins $309,000 Judgment Against Sexual Assault Accuser
Above: Professional baseball pitcher Trevor Bauer is seen during the 2024 Mexican Baseball League (LMB) King Series Championship match between his then-team Diablos Rojos del México and Sultanes de Monterrey at Estadio Mobil Super in Monterrey, Mexico. Image copyright: Carlos Santiago/Contributor/Eyepix Group/LightRocket via Getty Images

The Spin

Narrative A

Trevor Bauer has been vindicated. Lindsey Hill's fraudulent sexual assault claims, driven by her self-admitted attempt to win money from him, crumbled under scrutiny. Her inconsistent story, criminal history, and a warrant for her arrest expose her deceit. This $309,000 judgment against her for lying about a settlement confirms Bauer's innocence. The MLB, courts, and accusers owe him apologies for this smear that derailed his once incredible career.

Narrative B

Trevor Bauer's court win doesn't prove innocence, only that Lindsey Hill breached their settlement. His arrogance on social media, mocking teams like the Yankees while begging for a contract, shows he's exploiting the scandal for attention. No MLB team wants him — not only because of these accusations but because he's a divisive clubhouse presence. MLB doesn't promote alleged abusers, which is why he'll remain a pariah forever.

Metaculus Prediction


Articles on this story

Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters
Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters

Sign Up!
Sign Up Now!