03 September 2024

Daily Newsletter

Venezuela: Arrest Warrant Issued for Opposition Candidate

The Facts

  • On Monday, a Venezuelan judge issued an arrest order for former presidential candidate Edmundo González Urrutia, who claims victory in the July disputed election against Nicolás Maduro. The arrest warrant was issued after three missed court appearances.

  • Judge Edward Briceño issued the public prosecutor's office requested warrant against González, who stands accused of falsifying documents, inciting "disobedience," and the "usurpation" of public duties, among others. González denies the allegations.


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

This latest development is further evidence of the Maduro regime's crackdown on the opposition, which has seen it unfairly arrest thousands. In an attempt to maintain his grip on power, Maduro stole the election and is now using the public prosecutor's office to cover his tracks.

Establishment-critical narrative

González and his co-conspirator, Machado, refused to concede defeat and likely fabricated public election documents, and committed acts of sabotage. This warrant isn't the result of some Maduro conspiracy but simply Gonzalez's failure to appear in court. Everyone has to follow the law, even leaders of the opposition.

Nerd narrative

There is a 51% chance there will be a civil war in Venezuela before 2050, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

At Least 12 Migrants Die Trying to Cross English Channel

The Facts

  • French Interior Minister Gérald Darmanin told reporters that at least 12 migrants died Tuesday and two are missing after their boat capsized off the coast of France while trying to cross the English Channel to the UK.

  • The boat, which was carrying dozens of migrants, was first spotted by a French government-operated ship, with the French Navy deployed for a search and rescue mission.


The Spin

Left narrative

The British government is to blame for this tragedy. For years, it has responded to reports of migrant deaths with calls for tougher border security, resulting in asylum seekers taking more dangerous boat journeys. Those fleeing war and persecution will continue to attempt these trips, and it's up to French and British authorities to adopt policies that prevent these disasters.

Right narrative

While terrible, these tragedies on the open seas garner too much of a percentage of media attention compared to crimes being committed by migrants flocking to the UK without regard for immigration laws or whether they'll be able to make a life for themselves. It will always be appropriate for Britain to control its borders by any means necessary.

See sources

Harris Campaign Conducts Multiple Labor Day Activities

The Facts

  • Vice President Kamala Harris, the Democratic presidential nominee, visited swing states Michigan and Pennsylvania on Monday. Her running mate, Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, visited Wisconsin for Labor Day-themed events, including Harris appearing with President Joe Biden in Pennsylvania.

  • During the first joint appearance by the president and vice president since the former decided not to seek reelection and the latter ascended to the top of the ticket, Biden told the crowd, "If you elect Kamala Harris as president, it will be the best decision you have ever made."


The Spin

Democratic narrative

The Harris-Walz campaign couldn't have painted a starker difference between itself and the Trump campaign. While Harris and Walz were on the trail, spreading their message of dedication to labor and unions, Trump was nowhere to be found. Trump has often derided workers and unions throughout his career in business and politics, so it's no surprise the Harris team is dominating him on this issue.

Republican narrative

Being on the campaign trail and speaking to labor unions isn't worth much when American manufacturing has been contracting under the Biden-Harris administration. For the fifth straight month, the Institute for Supply Management manufacturing index came in under 50% (47.2 in August). This is a direct result of Biden-Harris policies that brought high inflation and interest rates.

Nerd narrative

There's a 54% chance that Kamala Harris will be elected US president in 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Pope Arrives in Indonesia, Kicks off 4-Nation Asia Trip

The Facts

  • Pope Francis arrived in Indonesia on Tuesday for a three-day visit — the first stop of his four-nation tour of the Asia-Pacific — accompanied by his entourage and journalists. The 87-year-old pontiff will also visit Papua New Guinea, East Timor, and Singapore over the next 12 days.

  • Indonesia's Minister of Religious Affairs Yaqut Cholil Qoumas received Pope Francis after the pontiff left the ITA Airways plane and entered the tarmac at Jakarta's Soekarno-Hatta International Airport.


The Spin

Narrative A

The day trip is an opportunity for the octogenarian leader of the world's Roman Catholics to highlight the global importance of inter-religious relationships and deepen dialogue between Christian and Muslim communities that continue to be tolerant and respectful. This historic visit will not only allow the pope to highlight key themes of his pontificate — including climate change and protection of the environment, but also cultivate peace, ensure prosperity, and provoke a jolt of change.

Narrative B

Pope Francis' physical health has undoubtedly declined with age. However, he has demonstrated that he remains mentally fit to lead the Catholic Church and has no intention of slowing down his outreach to faraway Catholics. His long and grueling day trip now — that many in the Vatican seemed skeptical of — underlines his liveliness and sends a message to those, including at senior levels in the church, who have been claiming that Pope Francis is running out of steam.

Nerd narrative

There's a 50% chance that the Catholic Church will elect a new pope by Jan. 2026, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Mexico's Lower House Passes Judicial Reform Despite Protests

The Facts

  • Mexico's Chamber of Deputies on Wednesday approved (359 to 135) Pres. Andrés Manuel López Obrador's judicial reform, moving the bill to the Senate where the ruling Morena party is close to a two-thirds supermajority.

  • This comes as demonstrators, including students and court employees who have gone on strike, gathered outside Congress on Tuesday and blocked access to the lower house in protest against the proposed overhaul.


The Spin

Establishment-critical narrative

It's urgent that Mexico reforms its judicial system, as most Mexicans have expressed their desire to be able to vote for judges and magistrates rather than being subject to the dictates of the judiciary elite. These changes are part of a broader push to bring more equality and social justice to Mexico.

Pro-establishment narrative

As Obrador enters his final month in office, his goal is clearly to consolidate his Morena party's power and reform the judicial system to install a totalitarian regime in Mexico. Instead of promoting true independence and democracy, these plans will do the opposite, by lowering professional standards and creating further vulnerabilities.

Nerd narrative

There's a 52% chance that the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA) will be extended promptly at its July 2026 joint review, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Clearview AI Fined $34M by Dutch Watchdog for 'Illegal Database'

The Facts

  • US facial recognition company Clearview AI has been fined approximately $33.7M by the Netherland's data protection authority for breaching the European Union's General Protection Regulation (GDPR).

  • Releasing a statement on Tuesday, the Dutch Data Protection Authority (DPA) claimed that Clearview holds "an illegal database with billions of photos of faces," including Dutch citizens, which have been scraped from the internet without consent.


The Spin

Narrative A

Now totaling nearly $100M in European fines alone, Clearview AI continues to engage in highly illegal and unethical activity by refusing to remove EU data from their systems. Facial recognition is a surveillance tool that continues to gather mounting opposition — threatening individual privacy. Without better international agreements, there is little Europe can do to force the US company to either pay up or wipe its illegal data.

Narrative B

While controversial, Clearview AI has been highly useful in the law enforcement space and has even extended to the realm of public defenders. There are documented cases where people have been found innocent of crimes thanks to the firm's technology. Because of the potential benefits to law enforcement and the public, assessing Clearview's record must be viewed with context even when the current discourse focuses almost entirely on privacy issues alone.

Nerd narrative

There is a 60% chance that an international AI regulatory agency for the oversight of transformative AI systems will be established before 2030, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Ex-Volkswagen Head Charged in Connection With 'Dieselgate'

The Facts

  • The criminal trial of former Volkswagen CEO Martin Winterkorn began Tuesday, nine years after the automobile manufacturer was found to have violated emissions testing rules.

  • The 2015 scandal for which Winterkorn is now on trial, dubbed "Dieselgate," involved the company installing software in 9M diesel-powered vehicles to create false emissions readings. This violated both European and US regulations.


The Spin

Left narrative

While it's important that the Volkswagen executives responsible for Dieselgate face justice, it can't be forgotten that their crimes severely damaged the climate and public health. Despite the discovery of Volkswagen's fraudulent emissions tests, millions of those toxic vehicles remained on the road, putting thousands of lives at risk of pollution-related death.

Right narrative

It's quite ironic that this trial begins just as Volkswagen announces the possibility of factory closures. The green energy theology behind this trial is the same one that's led to China outcompeting European auto manufacturers. It's also the same one whose policies forced European companies to backtrack on their impossible electric vehicle promises.

See sources

UAE Pardons 57 Bangladeshis Imprisoned for Staging Protests

The Facts

  • Pres. Sheikh Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan has pardoned 57 Bangladeshi citizens who were convicted in July for staging unauthorized protests in the United Arab Emirates against then-Bangladeshi Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina.

  • While the Abu Dhabi Federal Court of Appeal sentenced 53 people to 10 years in prison and 11 years to another, three received life sentences.


The Spin

Narrative A

Bangladeshis are the third largest expatriate group in the UAE and are expected to show utmost restraint on its soil. It's a given that they know that the oil-rich Gulf country bans unauthorized protests, prohibits speech that can encourage social unrest, and criminalizes defamation. This act of clemency — releasing Bangladeshi nationals who violated the country's laws — exemplifies Al Nahyan's compassionate leadership.

Narrative B

While this decision is welcomed, the Bangladeshi expatriates shouldn't have been detained, convicted, and sentenced for peacefully protesting against their erstwhile government in the first place. The UAE's reaction to a demonstration that had no criminal intent was extreme. The UAE must apologize for arbitrarily detaining the marchers, who neither engaged in violent acts nor used inflammatory language during their protests.

See sources

Few 'Minor Injuries' After Walz Motorcade Crash

The Facts

  • Several vehicles in Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz's motorcade Monday were involved in a crash on the way to the Democratic nominee for vice president's campaign event in Milwaukee. Walz was not hurt.

  • A pool reporter said one staff member in a press van suffered a broken arm. The same reporter said passengers in the van were "violently thrown forward" after a collision with another vehicle.


The Spin

Democratic narrative

Luckily, no one was seriously injured in this motorcade crash. Sometimes, these things happen when a lot of vehicles are traveling together at high speeds. In typical Walz fashion, the affable vice presidential candidate gave his speech without a hitch and then went out of his way to visit the hospital to check on his staffers.

Republican narrative

It's great that no one was seriously harmed in this crash. But it's also amazing how, after members of his staff and media were in a perilous situation, Walz — like Harris — refused to stop and speak with media members, including some involved in the accident. Nothing can stop the Democratic ticket from dodging questions.

See sources

Sign up to our daily newsletter