Trump Admin Backs Down on DC Police Chief Takeover

story

13 hrs ago

Above: Metropolitan Police Chief Pamela Smith at the Wilson Building on Aug. 11, 2025, in Washington, D.C. Image copyright: Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images

story last updated 13 hrs ago

The Spin

Democratic narrative

This ruling is clearly correct under the Home Rule Act, which grants limited presidential control but never intended to displace the chief or extend federal authority — evidenced by the Senate rejecting an amendment for presidential appointment. Trump is attempting a raw power grab, abusing the act's temporary provision. His crackdown also won't help, as crime is already at a 30-year low, negating any "emergency" justification.

The Washington Post The New York Times

Republican narrative

Trump's actions in D.C. are completely legal, as his only goal is to quickly take over, clean up the city and return it to its former glory. Police whistleblowers have also exposed crime stat manipulation, downgrading felonies to falsely lower rates, proving that federal help is needed. Federal intervention addresses this crisis, targeting soft-on-crime policies and juvenile crime surges, ensuring accountability and safety.

New York Post PJ Media