Trump Taps Jay Clayton as Next Intel Director
Is this an outstanding pick or a dangerously unqualified loyalty appointment?
Above: Jay Clayton in New York on June 3. Image credit: Michael Nagle/Bloomberg/Getty Images
The Spin
Republican narrative
Clayton is a top-shelf pick who has real-world experience, a sterling reputation and the full confidence of the president. Clayton has performed at the highest levels in both the public and private sectors, making him exactly the kind of leader the intelligence community needs. This is an outstanding nomination that deserves swift confirmation.
Democratic narrative
Clayton flat-out lacks the extensive intelligence expertise the law requires for the DNI role. Even his predecessor called him unqualified. This pick is driven by loyalty to Trump and willingness to amplify election conspiracy theories on TV rather than any genuine national security credentials, putting the country's entire intelligence apparatus at risk.
