28 June 2024

Daily Newsletter

Canada: UK's Tommy Robinson Arrested for Alleged Immigration Breach

The Facts

  • After giving a speech in Calgary, Alberta, Canada, earlier this week, right-wing British activist Tommy Robinson was arrested for what police said was an "outstanding immigration warrant."

  • Robinson, whose legal name is Stephen Yaxley-Lennon, was arrested by 10 officers outside the Carriage House Hotel and Conference Centre, where he gave a speech as part of an event with Canadian news website Rebel News.


The Spin

Left narrative

Tommy Robinson is an Islamophobic immigration hawk who ironically violated immigration laws. Given his criminal record, Robinson likely knew he would be arrested, which raises the question of whether this was a purposeful stunt aimed at raising money. His speaking tour has been an abject failure, so he certainly needed a way to raise funds from something other than ticket sales.

Right narrative

If Robinson was some dangerous, high-profile fugitive, why would he be allowed into Canada in the first place? Given the timing of his arrest and the fact that 10 undercover officers were used to handcuff him, it appears this was a planned move aimed at publicly punishing a conservative speaker. The government certainly knows how to enforce immigration laws against voices it doesn't like.

Nerd narrative

There is a 72% chance that the Conservative Party will win the most seats in the next Canadian federal election, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Scientist Says 'Ultra-Processed Foods' Need Tobacco-Style Warning Labels

The Facts

  • Brazilian scientist Carlos Monteiro, who coined the term "Ultra-Processed Foods" (UPFs) 15 years ago, says that the risk they pose to public health is great enough to warrant a campaign "like those against tobacco."

  • Ahead of his address at this week's International Congress on Obesity, Monteiro said UPFs and tobacco account for "numerous serious illnesses," and that both are made by marketing-driven industries selling something addictive and "pathogenic (dangerous) by design."


The Spin

Narrative A

This hyperbolic statement about UPFs is reductive, inaccurate, and does more harm than good. There is little evidence that UPFs are uniquely evil, as many nutritious shelf-stable foods are classified as ultra-processed. The public can also only absorb so much negative messaging at once, and will eventually tune out of public health warnings. The research maintains that a balanced diet is the most important part of nutrition.

Narrative B

The massive food conglomerates that push UPFs on the public are invested in sowing doubt about the harm their products cause. There's a growing mountain of evidence that shows the clear link between UPFs and negative health outcomes. The fight against UPFs is complicated by the extensive lobbying and financial power of the food industry, which is fighting tooth and nail to obfuscate its role in a public health crisis.

Nerd narrative

There is a 31% chance that an OECD country will achieve a 10% or greater reduction in the national rate of obesity for 3 consecutive years before 2030, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Ursula von der Leyen Nominated for Second European Commission Term

The Facts

  • At the European Council (EC) meeting in Brussels on Thursday, the European Union's leaders nominated Ursula von der Leyen for another five-year term as head of the European Commission.

  • Despite the rise of right-wing parties in European Parliament elections earlier this month, the EC's selection reflects continuity in the leadership of a political union that represents nearly 450M Europeans, with centrist pro-EU politicians maintaining the key positions.


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

When the European Council nominated Ursula von der Leyen for a second term as President of the European Commission, they made a wise choice. Following the impact of the European elections in early June, EU leaders have sent a strong signal of stability. The pro-EU traditionalists on the center-right, center-left, and liberal wings stood their ground against the far right that threatens the political stability of Europe. 

Establishment-critical narrative

The Council's nomination of von der Leyen is a disgrace. European voters clearly asked the EU to take another path than it has so far. The European leaders ignore the people's will and instead choose von der Leyen for another five-year term as Commission President. This is "democracy" as defined by the EU. Regardless of what the people say in elections, the elite does what it wants.

Cynical narrative

Securing the council's nomination was the easy part, but now Ursula von der Leyen faces the challenge of gaining majority support in an increasingly hostile European Parliament. Some analysts speculate that there could be as much as a 10% defection rate at the time of the July 18 vote in Parliament, which would leave her close to the 361 mark — just enough for approval. In 2019, von der Leyen won by a narrow margin of only 9 votes. This time around, the situation may become more dicey.

Nerd narrative

There's a 65% chance that Ursula von der Leyen will be re-appointed as President of the European Commission following the 2024 European elections, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Iran Votes for New President in Snap Elections

The Facts

  • Iran is voting in snap elections on Friday to choose a successor to Ebrahim Raisi after the then-president was killed along with other senior officials, in a helicopter crash in May.

  • Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf, parliamentary speaker and former air force commander of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, and former nuclear negotiator Saeed Jalili — both considered hardliners — are said to be the most prominent of the four candidates.


The Spin

Pro-Iran narrative

Despite the hopes of certain foreign powers that Raisi's unexpected death would plunge Iran into chaos, the snap election is proof of the country's political stability. Western and Israeli calls to boycott the vote are doomed to fail, and voter turnout is set to exceed that of the 2021 elections. While the results of the free elections are not yet known, they will prove the Iranians' resilience and autonomy and their will to choose their own path amid foreign efforts to bring Iran to its knees.

Anti-Iran narrative

This presidential election is essentially a sham, as elections under the Iranian regime are neither free nor fair. Having failed in its foreign policy and economic performance, the regime hopes to boost its legitimacy through a high voter turnout. While Pezeshkian may be the only candidate who aims to improve ties with the West and promises to ease social oppression, he also poses no vital threat to the theocratic system. Iranians deserve change, but this so-called election is unlikely to deliver it.

Nerd narrative

There is a 5.5% chance that Ali Khamenei will cease to be the Supreme Leader of Iran in 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Trump and Biden Face Off in First 2024 Presidential Debate

The Facts

  • US Pres. Joe Biden and former Pres. Donald Trump squared off in their first debate ahead of the 2024 election Thursday night in Atlanta, Georgia.

  • They discussed issues ranging from Biden's age and how Trump dealt with Jan. 6 to immigration and the wars in Gaza and Ukraine.


The Spin

Pro-Trump narrative

As Donald Trump appeared more statesmanlike than ever before, Biden exposed his mental decline and inability to win re-election. While the left-wing mainstream media couldn't help but dish out bogus fact-checks on Trump, even they were publicly decrying Biden's performance and fitness for office. Even if they do replace Biden, Trump proved he can take on anyone the Democrats throw at him.

Anti-Trump narrative

Biden's performance is irrelevant to the fact that Trump lied about every issue Americans care about most. From abortion rights and terror attacks to the national debt and Biden's corruption allegations, Trump projected all the failures of his administration onto a man who's made the country more prosperous and safe. The country knows Trump is a liar, which is why he's losing this election race.

Narrative C

President Biden has done an incredible job bringing America back to the positive days of pre-Trumpism, but last night's debate showed, unfortunately, that he can't physically continue. The Democratic Party and its leader must put the country first if they wish to prevent another dreadful Trump term.

Nerd narrative

There is an 80% chance that Joe Biden will be the Democratic nominee for the 2024 US Presidential Election, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Report: NKorea Executed 22-Year-Old For Disseminating K-pop

The Facts

  • According to South Korea's newly released 2024 Report on North Korean Human Rights, Pyongyang has publicly executed a 22-year-old man for consuming and sharing 70 K-pop songs and three South Korean films.

  • This comes as one of the 649 North Korean defectors who testified for the report recounted witnessing the execution of a young man from South Hwanghae province in 2022.


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

South Korean pop culture threatens the Northern regime's control and ideology. The vibrant fashion, music, and slang represent a stark contrast to a strict, state-controlled culture. Pyongyang fears that exposure to an affluent and free lifestyle could inspire discontent and admiration among its citizens, undermining the regime's authority. With the North in dire economic straits, any foreign influence could erode the regime's legitimacy and ideological grip on its people.

Establishment-critical narrative

There's no evidence that Pyongyang carried out the execution of the young man, as the South claims. What is known for sure is that South Korean pop culture has troublesome issues beneath its glamorous surface. For instance, the K-pop industry is riddled with mistreatment, exploitation, and abuse, including slave-like contracts and sexual harassment. When North Korea fights against the dissemination of such content, it's also taking a stance against all these problems.

Nerd narrative

There's a 50% chance North Korea will become a democracy by October 2075, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Report: US Readies to Evacuate Americans From Lebanon

The Facts

  • As cross-border clashes continue to escalate between Israeli forces and Iran-backed Hezbollah fighters in Lebanon, the US Dept. of Defense is moving military assets closer to the region over fears American citizens may soon need to be evacuated from Lebanon, US military officials told NBC News on Thursday.

  • According to the publication's sources, the Pentagon moved the USS Wasp — an amphibious assault ship — to the Mediterranean on Wednesday. There, it joined the USS Oak Hill, a dock landing ship, in the case that US Marines were needed to carry out what is known as a "Military Assisted Departure."


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

The US is doing all it can to prevent a war between Israel and Iran's Hezbollah fighters in Lebanon. This move is simply to ensure that if that worst-case scenario takes place, the US is best placed to take immediate action, rather than to lag behind in its response.

Pro-Israel narrative

While Israel is thankful to the US for ammunition and intelligence sharing, America's policy on Hezbollah — which it considers a terrorist group — is bewildering. Americans need to realize that pushing back the Iran-backed group is essential for Israel's national security — and it's in the US interest as well.

Pro-Iran narrative

The regional resistance is an essential bulwark against Israel's occupation, as well as Israel's increasing attacks on Lebanon. Iran will continue these important efforts to resist the crimes of the Israeli regime and will not hesitate to escalate its response if Israel does not end its ongoing aggression.

Nerd narrative

There's a 86% chance that there will be 1K or more deaths due to armed conflict between Israel and Hezbollah before 2025, according to the Metaculus community prediction.

See sources

Former Police Chief Charged in Uvalde School Shooting

The Facts

  • On Thursday, the police chief of Uvalde, Texas, during the 2022 Robb Elementary school shooting, Pete Arredondo, was indicted on 10 counts of felony child endangerment over the law enforcement response to the mass shooting.

  • These are the first criminal charges laid against police for the shooting that left 19 children and two teachers dead. Arredondo was released the same day on a $10K bond, while a second officer was also indicted for his role in the police response.


The Spin

Democratic narrative

The tragedy in Uvalde was a failure on all levels of government. The police on scene violated every principle they've been taught regarding active shooters, as incompetence and cowardice allowed the shooter to continue his massacre unabated. While this indictment will hopefully afford the families of those affected some closure for the events of that awful day, there is still no political will to address the root issue of guns in America.

Republican narrative

The police response at Robb Elementary was disastrous, but the political hijacking of this case for gun control causes has obscured that. The lesson we should learn is that guns do indeed keep us safer, and it was the failure of the police to use them soon enough that allowed the tragedy to unfold. These indictments lay bare that guns are not the issue, as good people with guns do stop tragedies.

Nerd narrative

There's a 50% chance that there will be at least 1.41 small firearms per capita in the US in 2029, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

SCOTUS Overturns 1984 Precedent, Limiting Federal Agencies' Authority

The Facts

  • The US Supreme Court (SCOTUS) on Friday issued a 6-3 ruling, along ideological lines, to overturn the court's 1984 Chevron v. Natural Resources Defense Council, which told courts to defer to executive branch agencies regarding the interpretation of federal laws.

  • The case began in 2020 when fishermen from Rhode Island and New Jersey challenged a law — imposed by the National Marine Fisheries Service — requiring them to pay for data collection and fishing operation monitors that cost up to $700 per day.


The Spin

Left narrative

If SCOTUS was really looking to reflect the founders' understanding of executive authority, it would've relied on the precedent of federal personnel — including customs officers and tax collectors — being given broad discretion in regulating since the country's earliest days. Instead, SCOTUS has put America's environment and health at risk because judges with no expertise on these matters will be determining regulation.

Right narrative

SCOTUS has taken an important step in reining in the bureaucratic deep state so that unelected, anonymous bureaucrats won't be able to hide behind their so-called expertise when they shove politically motivated regulations into the lives of citizens and their businesses. But this is just a first step because politically-motivated judges will still be able enforce bureaucratic regulations.

Nerd narrative

There's a 38% chance that SCOTUS changes its membership size before Jan. 1, 2050, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Lakers Make History Drafting Bronny James, Pairing Him With His Father

The Facts

  • Basketball legend LeBron James and his son, LeBron "Bronny" James Jr. will become the first-son duo in NBA history to play on the same team after the Los Angeles Lakers selected the younger James with the 55th pick of the 2024 NBA Draft on Thursday.

  • After one season at the University of Southern California (USC), Bronny wasn't considered a top prospect by most draft analysts, however, his future was one of the top storylines from this year's draft due to his father's immense status in the league.


The Spin

Narrative A

The Lakers’ drafting of Bronny James and uniting him on the same team as his father exemplifies the beauty of sports. Raised without a father, LeBron James Sr. overcame childhood adversity to become not only a superstar basketball player but also a fantastic dad. Some may complain about nepotism or try to make this story about Rich Paul pushing other teams away, but at the end of the day, the focus should be on a father realizing his dream and giving his children what he never had.

Narrative B

There's certainly a heartwarming element of LeBron James fulfilling his dream of playing alongside his son, but Bronny's selection will increase the weighty pressure on his shoulders. It's clear that the younger James will never come close to the player that his father is, and playing alongside him will only make it harder for Bronny to carve out a career independent of his legendary dad. This move also shows that the Lakers are more committed to appeasing a year-old player than building a team.

Nerd narrative

There is a 50% chance that LeBron James will have scored at least 42.7K or more regular season points when he retires, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Sign up to our daily newsletter