09 September 2024

Daily Newsletter

Venezuela's Opposition Candidate Flees to Exile in Spain

The Facts

  • Venezuela's opposition candidate Edmundo González arrived in Spain on Sunday, where he was granted political asylum, after fleeing his own country where he faced an arrest warrant for electoral sabotage and other charges related to the disputed presidential election.

  • Despite official claims that González himself requested political asylum from Spain, and was then granted the due safe conducts, sources alleged to El País that his exile is the result of talks that involved some of Nicolás Maduro's closest allies.


The Spin

Narrative A

Sadly, the president-elect had no option other than to flee to Spain, especially as actions against the Argentine embassy made it clear that there would be no such thing as a safe haven in Venezuela. From exile, González will be able to connect with the diaspora to help those fighting at home to ensure respect for the will of the people.

Narrative B

It's only natural that opposition leaders are expressing words of encouragement after González left the country, but Venezuelans are all too familiar with what happens now. From exile, the president-elect will see his leadership collapse and become a joke to the government. María Corina Machado is now the only hope for Venezuela.

Establishment-critical narrative

Once again, Nicolás Maduro and his government have shown good faith when it comes to dealing with US-backed opposition figures. Despite an arrest warrant for González on multiple charges including conspiracy and forgery of public documents, authorities in Venezuela granted him safe passage to leave the country so that peace can prevail.

Nerd narrative

There's a 55% chance that if Nicolás Maduro is inaugurated in January 2025, there will be a civil war in Venezuela before 2050, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Algeria: Pres. Tebboune Wins Second Term

The Facts

  • Algeria's incumbent Pres. Abdelmadjid Tebboune has been re-elected to a second term in office, winning 95% of the votes polled on Saturday.

  • According to the country's electoral commission, Tebboune's main rivals, Abdelaali Hassani Cherif and Youcef Aouchiche, secured 3% and 2% of the votes, respectively.


The Spin

Narrative A

Tebboune's re-election promises stability for Algeria, allowing the government to address deeper issues. His increased popular support, bolstered by expanded social spending from oil and gas revenues, suggests a mandate for continuity. The backing of major political parties, unions, and the security apparatus ensures a strong foundation for governance. Tebboune's experience and established relationships within the system position him to navigate Algeria's complex political landscape and initiate much-needed reforms.

Narrative B

Algerian democracy has become largely performative, with Tebboune's re-election revealing the system's true nature. The election, hastily moved to September, was a sham as his victory was guaranteed by military backing. Opposition candidates are little more than window dressing in a political landscape marked by repression, economic stagnation, and mass disillusionment. As Algerians increasingly turn away from a system that betrays them, the dream of genuine democracy remains distant.

Nerd narrative

There's a 10% chance that Algeria will experience a successful coup d'etat before 2040, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Poll: Harris, Trump Deadlocked as Debate Nears

The Facts

  • According to a national survey by the New York Times and Siena College, Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump and Democrat Kamala Harris are polling "neck and neck" less than two months before election day.

  • A day before Harris' first televised debate against Trump in Pittsburg, Pa., the poll, which ran from Sept. 3-6, shows Trump leading Harris by one point, 48%-47% — well within the survey's three percentage point margin of error.


The Spin

Republican narrative

The most obvious reason for this poll is that Harris' post-nomination honeymoon phase is over and the public is beginning to see her flaws as a candidate. As she braces for her first debate, she won't only deal with the fact that Trump is better than her on immigration and the economy, but that Trump is statistically likely to beat her on Election Day should he remain within a point or two in the polls.

Democratic narrative

Harris, as vice presidents have historically done in the past, has been forced to take heat for her boss' challenges but receive little credit for his successes. Harris has an opportunity to show that she's her own candidate with new and popular ideas. The American people no longer care about "Vice President Harris" — they're eager to hear how "President Harris" would uplift the country after defeating the bitterly divisive and dangerous Trump campaign.

Nerd narrative

There is a 51% chance Vice President Kamala Harris will be elected US President in 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Bangladesh Seeks Sheikh Hasina's Extradition from India

The Facts

  • Bangladesh is seeking to extradite former Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina from India, where she fled on Aug. 5 following mass protests against her.

  • Mohammad Tajul Islam, chief prosecutor of Bangladesh's International Crimes Tribunal, said on Sunday that Hasina will be tried for "mass killings" that allegedly took place during the student-led protests.


The Spin

Narrative A

India must act swiftly and hand Sheikh Hasina over to Bangladesh so she can face justice for her alleged crimes. With growing demands for accountability coming from victims and political opponents, India's continued harboring of Hasina risks further straining its relations with Bangladesh. It's time for New Delhi to help restore trust and stability between the two nations.

Narrative B

As Bangladesh confronts its past, it needs to avoid vindictiveness against Hasina and refrain from victimizing her. While those who suffered enforced disappearances deserve justice and truth, healing requires balance and compassion. Pursuing retribution against a former leader could deepen divisions and impede reconciliation. Bangladesh must avoid taking the easy path.

Nerd narrative

There's a 40% chance that Bangladesh will hold parliamentary elections within six months of Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina's Aug. 5, 2024 ouster, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Three Israelis Shot Dead at West Bank-Jordan Crossing

The Facts

  • Three Israeli civilian guards were killed on Sunday morning at the West Bank-Jordan border crossing after a gunman opened fire in a commercial cargo terminal under Israeli control at the King Hussein/Allenby Bridge.

  • The shooter — identified as Maher Jazi, a 39-year-old truck driver from Jordan — was killed at the scene by security personnel. His truck was checked for explosives and Israeli forces searched the area for additional assailants.


The Spin

Pro-Israel narrative

Israel is under attack as Iran's axis of evil conducts a multi-front war on Israel. The heinous Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas massacre was just the start, with Hezbollah and the Houthis following suit. To make things worse, this rising violence has also encouraged lone-wolf terrorists and terrorist groups in the West Bank and elsewhere to carry out deadly attacks.

Pro-Palestine narrative

There are inhumane crimes of occupation against Palestinians in the West Bank and the genocide campaign in Gaza. As long as Israel fails to work towards a cease-fire and end its occupation in Palestine, it will be primarily responsible for flare-ups of violence taking place against the backdrop of a brutal occupation.

Nerd narrative

There is a 5% chance an Israel-Hamas conflict ceasefire lasting at least 30 days will be agreed to before November 5th, 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

RFK Jr. Wins Removal From Ballot in Two Swing States

The Facts

  • Former independent candidate for president Robert F. Kennedy Jr. on Friday had his request to have his name removed from the ballot in North Carolina and Michigan granted by separate court rulings.

  • In North Carolina, the intermediate-level Court of Appeals — a three-judge panel — ordered the state to stop mailing ballots with Kennedy's name on them and requested a trial judge order the State Board of Elections to distribute ones without Kennedy's name on them. A similar court in Michigan ruled Kennedy's name should be removed from that state's ballots.


The Spin

Republican narrative

This is a triumph for Kennedy and justice. If someone doesn't want to be included on a ballot, it's their right. In this case, Kennedy is admirably trying to avoid being a spoiler to his candidate of choice, Trump. Democrats — who fought Kennedy's access to the ballot in the first place — want to keep him on because it's politically advantageous to them, but their argument falls flat in contrast to election laws.

Democratic narrative

Kennedy is only fighting to get off the ballot in places he thinks he can help Trump. This isn't about his individual rights, but his political games — after he fought so hard to get on the ballot in many states. Aside from the impact he could have on Harris' chances, he's exacting an undue administrative burden on states and creating problematic chaos where there need not be any.

Nerd narrative

There's a 1% chance that a third-party or independent candidate will win at least 5% of the popular vote in the 2024 US presidential election, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Nigeria: Over 50 Killed in Fuel Tanker Explosion

The Facts

  • At least 59 people have died after a fuel tanker collided with a lorry carrying travelers and cattle in central Nigeria's Niger state Sunday.

  • According to the Niger State Emergency Management Agency, rescue operations were underway at the site of the accident, and the deceased were given a mass burial.


The Spin

Narrative A

With fatal crashes along major roads in Nigeria becoming a norm, it's clear the country's road safety measures are inadequate. The poor state of roads and the absence of an efficient railway system to transport cargo, especially fuel, has caused tremendous loss of life and property. It's time the government recognizes road traffic accidents as a critical issue that demands immediate attention.

Narrative B

Reckless driving, overloading, overspeeding, and poorly maintained vehicles account for more than half of road accident-related deaths in Nigeria. While the cause of Sunday's accident is yet to be determined, the law must punish all drivers who disrespect road traffic regulations and their licenses must be suspended for endangering lives. Individuals must bear responsibility for dangerous behavior.

Nerd narrative

There's a 2% chance that Nigeria will have a coup before 2025, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

UK: Labour Faces Union Backlash Over Winter Fuel Allowance Cut

The Facts

  • UK trade union Unite has called for a "U-turn" on plans to revoke the winter fuel payment for over 10M pensioners — which will be voted on in the House of Commons on Tuesday.

  • The winter fuel payment was introduced in 1997 by Gordon Brown to help the elderly pay for heating during winter. In July, Chancellor Rachel Reeves announced that the previously universal payment would now be given only to those who receive pension credit.


The Spin

Labour Party narrative

Starmer and his cabinet members didn't come to this decision lightly, and they understood the concerns of the British public. However, this policy will not affect the poorest in society and will remain available for many who still have yet to apply for the winter fuel allowance. Unfortunately, this is a necessary budget cut to fill a massive budget hole left by the previous Conservative government.

Establishment-critical narrative

Cutting the winter fuel allowance is the wrong approach to Labour's goal of balancing the budget. When faced with the choice of either taxing the ultra-wealthy 1% of their assets or removing essential welfare for millions of pensioners, Starmer has shown where his true intentions lie. While tough choices may certainly be necessary, these must not be made at the expense of the very people Labour is meant to protect.

Right narrative

Labour's restriction of the winter fuel allowance is a direct result of the party's weak decision to succumb to union demands for extortionate pay rises. Having held the country hostage for more money, unions now cry injustice on behalf of the pensioners left for dead as a result of their very own greed. The actions of the Labour Party and their virtue-signaling union partners are a disgrace to the nation.

Nerd narrative

There is a 50% chance that Keir Starmer's approval rating will be at least 34.4% on Sept. 18, 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Boeing, Union Agree on New Contract

The Facts

  • Boeing and its largest union, the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers, Sunday announced they've agreed on a new contract — averting a strike if it's ratified.

  • The new agreement calls for the 33K union workers to get pay raises of 25% over four years. Average wages will rise 33% because of seniority step increases, but the union had been seeking a 40% rise.


The Spin

Narrative A

This deal shows that Ortberg is well-positioned for this role. Bathed in a sea of bad publicity and sinking value, Ortberg didn't just cut a deal that shows the company values its employees and meets the union halfway — and gives union leaders a contract to be proud of — but also commits to building in the Pacific Northwest, where there's the best chance for Boeing to complete its projects correctly. Boeing is on the path to recovery.

Narrative B

The union had all the leverage here, considering the dire straits Boeing has found itself in. However, the union negotiated a fair deal and made some concessions. So the onus is now on the company to fulfill its promises and commit to the safety improvements it has been talking about since Ortberg ascended to the chief executive role. Boeing's future actions, not rhetoric, will determine whether the company survives.

Nerd narrative

There's a 1% chance that Boeing will release a new midsize aircraft, likely to be called the 797, into commercial service before Jan. 1, 2030, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Sign up to our daily newsletter